Pointing Finger

Never Be Defensive. It’s Not to Your Benefit.

It’s a fact of life. Sooner or later, someone is going to accuse you of something, or confront you about an issue, or say something mean that’s intended to hurt you, or make an unflattering comment about you. And when they do, your natural instinct will be (and this is true of all of us)  to retaliate and be defensive—which is exactly why you have to fight those urges and do the opposite—if you want to succeed well.

Very few people ever learn this lesson, but if you will, you’ll discover that it’s invaluable. In fact, just to give you a glimpse into why this skill is so valuable to learn, here are four reasons why you’ll want to make the non-defensive choice when someone says something accusatory or inappropriate.

1. You never want to let anyone else control you

Whenever you choose to be defensive, you’re allowing the other person to control you and your emotions. You’re allowing them to get “under your skin.” You’re allowing them to control the conversation. And you’re allowing them to control how you feel. Why should you ever let someone do that to you? Remain in control of you. They can’t control you unless you give them control. So, don’t!

2. There may be some truth in what they’re saying

Whenever you choose to be defensive, you immediately stop listening and start defending yourself and your actions—and that’s a problem.  Even if someone has a bad motive for saying what they’re saying, that doesn’t mean there might not be something truthful in their comments. If you’re too busy defending yourself, you can’t hear that—which means you’ll end up missing a great opportunity for growth.

Even in my darkest moments, when people have done and said unbelievably cruel and untruthful things, I’ve often learned a lot about me and how I can become a better person. What others may intend for evil, God often uses for good. So, don’t stop listening just to defend yourself.

3.You never want to appear like a fool

Solomon got it right, years ago, when he said, “A fool gives full vent to his anger, but a wise man keeps himself under control.” Proverbs 29:11. Whenever you get defensive, you allow your anger to blind you—which then usually leads to conflict and words poorly spoken (because they haven’t been thought through), which then makes you the person in the wrong. Don’t be foolish. Keep yourself under control no matter what anyone says.

4. Being in control is an act of maturity and wisdom

Whenever you or I encounter someone who is unruffled by the comments or accusations of others, we instinctively think, “Now there’s someone who’s mature.” And isn’t that what you want people to say about you?

I know that what I’m sharing is difficult. Wanting to defend yourself is natural. But then again, maturity isn’t about doing what feels natural. It’s about doing what’s right. One of my favorite passages from Solomon comes from Proverbs 9:8-9

“Do not rebuke a mocker or he will hate you;
rebuke a wise man and he will love you.
Instruct a wise man and he will be wiser still;
teach a righteous man and he will add to his learning.”

Learning to not be defensive and to listen to what someone is saying (even if their motives are wrong) is what wise people do. If we get defensive, we never get to that point.

So, what should you do? Here are a few thoughts.

1. Refuse to lash back

Force yourself to never attack back. Make it a rule. “Whenever someone attacks me, I won’t attack back.” Or, “Whenever someone confronts me, I won’t confront back.” Set it as a standard, and keep it. This is one of my rules and you won’t regret it.

2. Practice reflective listening

This forces you to listen. “So, you feel ________ because of ________.” The first blank is for the emotion (angry, hurt, frustrated, etc.) and the second if the action/behavior. “So, you feel angry because I didn’t show up on time again.” This works in all situations—at work, with a spouse, with friends, with children, etc. You’ll be amazed at how fast this can “cool” people off.

3. Use clarifying questions

When people are upset, they rarely think logically. So, they’ll often throw things at you that are illogical and downright ridiculous. For example, someone could say to you, in response to a grammatical error, “You’re the stupidest person I’ve ever met. How did you ever graduate from college?”

Rather than get defensive, in a calm and collected manner, you should ask a clarifying question like the following. “So, let me see if I’m hearing you correctly. You believe that because I forgot one comma and missed correcting ‘their” when it should have been ‘there,’ that I’m the stupidest person you’ve ever met and that my alma mater made a grave mistake by granting me a diploma when they should have flunked me. Is that correct?”

4. Remember that who you are and what you do are two separate things

When people are upset, they often confuse the two and translate someone’s actions into an indictment about the other person’s character. In the example above, someone took a grammatical mistake and turned it into a character issue (“you’re stupid”).

I’ll write an entire lesson about this issue because it’s so important, but for now, just remember that when people make accusations about you and your character, they’re usually jumping from an action to a character statement—and that’s rarely accurate. An action is simply that, an action.

5. Make being in control of your emotions one of your life goals

One of the affirmations I regularly repeat to myself is, “I will be in control of my emotions, decisions, actions and thoughts—and will not give the power of these over to anyone or anything else.” None of us can control those who will say cruel or difficult things to us. However, we can control ourselves. So, make that your goal. And one of the best tests of whether or not you actually own that goal will be how well you respond when someone attacks or accuses or confronts you about something that you don’t believe is justified.

6. Force yourself to ask if there’s any truth in their statements

This is the hardest one of all, but whenever someone confronts you about something or accuses you of something, you need to force yourself to ask the key question, “Is there any kernel of truth in what they’re saying that I need to hear?” Sometimes there isn’t. But frequently there is. So, don’t be defensive. Instead use their moment of accusation as a moment for you to consider if that might be an opportunity for you to use for your own personal growth.

Now, having said all that, you may be wondering, “Well, is it ever okay to defend myself?” Absolutely. But not in the heat of the moment. Being defensive and defending yourself are two completely different things. Defending yourself is about the truth and you should do that when you need to—but only when you’re calm and in control (and that usually requires some time and space between when the negative comments were made and your defense).

Learning how to not be defensive is a great life skill. Once you master it, using the six strategies above, you’ll realize how incredibly valuable a skill it is. And when you’re in control, you’ll end up having the kind of clarity of thought that you’ll need to defuse the situation and find a solution ten times faster than you would have if you’d given in to being defensive (plus you won’t end up saying something that you shouldn’t have that would have made the problem even worse).

Anyway you add it up, the absolute best strategy you can ever use when someone accuses you or confronts you of something is to never be defensive. It’s not to your benefit.

To your accelerated success!

P.S. One last thought. The Apostle Peter had some great advice about how to deal with this issue, using Jesus as an example. In 1 Peter 2:23 he wrote

“When they hurled their insults at him, he did not retaliate; when he suffered, he made no threats. Instead he entrusted himself to him who judges justly.” 

At the end of the day, it’s not your job to prove yourself to someone else. Instead, entrust yourself to your Heavenly Father and let Him right any wrongs on your behalf. He’s much better at that than you or I could or ever will be.

Flick photo by Stuart Richards

Subscribe to these posts

If you'd like to have these life lessons sent directly to your email inbox, just enter your email address below (and don't forget to click the link in the confirmation email from feed burner).

, , , , ,

2 Responses to Never Be Defensive. It’s Not to Your Benefit.

  1. Harry February 7, 2015 at 7:19 pm #

    Thank you Mr. Johnson. This article has blessed me. This is a great and mindful and spiritual writeup about why it is important to not be so defensive — it’s a bit of a form of pride when someone makes you feel the position you hold is weak and you lash back for no other reason than your pride/ego has been wounded.

    Taking Jesus’ advice, we do not retaliate — and yet we sometimes end up feeling pain from the hurt that led to our showing humility and restraint. But that is precisely how we are command to model Christ and and it is but a small cross to bear when that communication is with those we love and care for.

    As we, per Mr. Johnson’s advise in #6, become self-aware and reflect on what just transpired (and why) in the (say) communication “tiff”, we recall Christ is the only One who can judge us fairly, prods us into seeking forgiveness when we were/are part of the problem, nudges us to un-reluctantly and quickly forgive the other for their sins, and continues to love us unconditionally, That self-awareness will serve us well and is a huge blessing.

    Thank you!

    • Bruce February 23, 2015 at 8:14 pm #

      Harry, thank you for your kind words and insightful comments. Self-awareness, humility, restraint, obedience, trusting God, offering forgiveness—all of those are tall orders for anyone to execute on … and yet are absolutely necessary to live a life well lived. Thanks again! Bruce

Leave a Reply